Is Your Canadian Trucking Company Subject to U.S. Federal Income Tax?

Quick Links

Is Your Canadian Trucking Company Subject to U.S. Federal Income Tax?

The Canadian trucking company may be subject to U.S. federal income tax depending on the following two questions:

The first question is whether the Canadian company is engaged in a U.S. trade or business (USTB).

and

The second question is whether the Canadian company’s income is effectively connected with that U.S. trade or business (ECI).

First, let’s look at the first question: whether the Canadian company is carrying on a U.S. trade or business.

Step 1 — Does Your Company Have a U.S. Trade or Business?

The Canadian trucking company may need to assess whether it has any U.S. federal income tax obligations by looking at the following question:

Whether the Canadian trucking company is engaged in a U.S. trade or business (USTB).

The Internal Revenue Code does not provide one comprehensive definition of a U.S. Trade or Business (USTB).

The determination generally depends on the nature, frequency, and extent of the company’s activities in the United States.

The IRS states that USTB consists of considerable, continuous, and regular profit-seeking activities carried out within the United States.

Recent court rulings have examined when a foreign person’s activities constitute a USTB.

For example, in the case of YA Global Investments, LP v. Commissioner (2023), the U.S. Tax Court decided that a foreign investment fund carried out a USTB via its U.S.-based investment manager. The court found that the manager acted as the fund’s agent and conducted continuous, regular, and profit-oriented activities on the fund’s behalf.

On the other hand, in Free-Pacheco v. United States (2014), the U.S. Court of Federal Claims looked at whether a Mexican nonresident alien’s slot machine gambling in Las Vegas counted as a USTB. The court found that the taxpayer did not show his gambling from 2007 to 2010 was regular, ongoing, or intended to make a profit. As a result, the court decided his activities did not qualify as a USTB.

Let us now examine whether the Canadian trucking companies’ activities count as considerable, continuous, and regular profit-seeking activities in the United States.

Consider a Canadian trucking company that transports freight between Canada and the United States.

The head office of the company is located in Canada, and it has no presence in the United States, for example, not in the form of an office, a warehouse, or some other permanent facility.

Canadian drivers frequently enter the United States to collect and deliver freight. They then operate the company’s trucks, provide transportation services, and get paid.

The main question is whether these activities are considerable, continuous, and profit-seeking enough to be classified as a trade or business in the United States.

First, let’s look at what kind of activities qualify as profit-seeking to meet the USTB standard.

Are the Activities Profit-Seeking?

The first point is the nature of the activities being performed.

The drivers are not performing incidental or unrelated activities in the United States. They perform the company’s core revenue-generating business—transporting freight. The company earns revenue from the transportation services its drivers and trucks perform.

Therefore, if a Canadian company regularly sends its employees to the United States to perform transportation-related services, those U.S. activities are likely to be considered part of its profit-seeking business.

This is not affected by the fact that the company’s headquarters are located in Canada. The relevant question is where the Canadian company actually conducts its business activities, not where it is incorporated or maintains its headquarters.

Therefore, regularly performing these profit-seeking activities in the United States may indicate that the Canadian company is engaged in a U.S. trade or business.

Next, let’s look at what kind of activities qualify as continuous and regular to meet the USTB standard.

Are the Activities Continuous and Regular?

The next question that may determine USTB is how frequently and consistently the Canadian company conducts the transportation-related activities in the United States.

A single trip will generally not support the argument that the company’s U.S. activities are continuous and regular.

However, the company may perform frequent U.S. pickups and deliveries as part of its ordinary business. This may indicate a continuing pattern of U.S. business activity.

No fixed number of trips or days automatically makes activities continuous and regular.

The determination depends on the company’s overall activity pattern.

For example, the following facts may be relevant:

  • Frequency: How often do the company’s trucks and drivers enter the United States?
  • Duration: How much amount of time do the Canadian drivers actually spend performing transportation activities in the United States?
  • Regularity: Is the Canadian company regularly involved in U.S. pickups and deliveries as part of the company’s normal operations?
  • Customer contracts: Does the company regularly enter into contracts requiring transportation services involving the United States?
  • U.S. revenue-generating activities: Does the company regularly earn transportation revenue from services performed in the United States?
  • Other U.S. activities: Does the Canadian company have any other U.S .-based activities apart from transportation? These may include sales, dispatch, customer service, or vehicle maintenance in the United States.

The more frequent and consistent these activities are, the stronger the argument that the company is conducting a continuing business operation in the United States.

Next, let’s look at what kind of activities qualify as considerable to meet the USTB standard.

Are the Activities Considerable?

The final question that determines U.S. Trade or Business (USTB) is whether the Canadian company’s U.S. activities are considerable. This implies whether such activities in the U.S. are sufficiently substantial or significant.

In order to determine whether the activities are considerable, one should look at what the company actually does in the United States. This does not simply mean counting the number of trips.

For a trucking company, the transport of goods is not a small-scale operation; it is, in fact, the main aspect of its business.

In this instance, the drivers of the Canadian company frequently go into the United States in order to pick up or deliver freight, using the company’s trucks to carry out the transportation services. It follows that these activities could constitute a major component of the company’s regular business operations.

The analysis may therefore consider the extent to which the company’s employees, vehicles, time, contracts, and other business resources are devoted to activities performed in the United States.

Overall Analysis

From the above analysis, a Canadian trucking company is more likely to have considerable, continuous, and profit-seeking activities in the United States if the following happens:

Those people who drive the vehicle often go into the United States and carry out the company’s regular transportation business there.

The lack of a U.S. office or warehouse by itself does not prevent the company from having a USTB. The study, on the other hand, examines the company’s actual operations in the United States.

In cases where Canadian employees regularly make use of company trucks and other resources to carry out revenue-producing transportation services in the U.S., those activities could form a solid basis for USTB.

The conclusion, however, remains dependent on the company’s specific facts and circumstances.

The IRS also describes a USTB as performing personal services in the United States. Let’s analyze how the Canadian trucking companies’ activities qualify as performing personal services in the United States.

26 U.S. Code §864(b) generally provides that performing personal services in the United States constitutes a U.S. trade or business, subject to certain statutory exceptions.

This rule may be particularly relevant to a Canadian trucking company because its drivers may physically perform transportation services in the United States.

For example, assume a Canadian driver enters the United States, picks up freight in Michigan, and delivers it to a customer in Ohio. The driver is physically performing transportation services within the United States. These services are also being performed as part of the Canadian company’s transportation business.

Accordingly, the company’s activities may implicate the personal-services rule under §864(b) even though the company has no U.S. office or warehouse.

The company should still look into the specific exceptions to the personal services rule under §864(b) and the applicable regulations based on its facts.

Do Any Exceptions to the Personal Services Rule Apply?

Generally, the performance of personal services in the U.S. may constitute a U.S. trade or business (USTB). But the statute includes an exception that may prevent certain personal services from constituting a USTB.

The exception can apply under IRC §864(b)(1) when a foreign individual performs personal services in the U.S., provided all the following three conditions are met:

  1. Foreign employer: The services are performed for a foreign employer that is not engaged in a U.S. trade or business, or for a foreign office of a U.S. person.
  2. 90-day limit: The individual is present in the United States for no more than 90 days during the tax year.
  3. $3,000 compensation limit: The individual receives no more than $3,000 in total compensation for the services performed in the United States.

If any one of these conditions is not met, the exception does not apply. The individual’s U.S. activities should then be evaluated under the general U.S. trade or business rules.

Let’s understand how the personal services exception may apply to Canadian truck drivers through a simple example.

Example

A Canadian trucking company sends one of its Canadian drivers, a non-US resident alien, to deliver a load to Chicago. The driver spends four days in the United States and receives $1,200 for the trip. The Canadian company has no U.S. terminal, office, or other U.S. operations.

In this example, the following three conditions are met:

  • Less than 90 days: The Canadian driver is present in the U.S. for 4 days, which is less than 90 days during the tax year.
  • Less than $3,000 Compensation: The driver received $1,200 for the U.S. trip, which is less than the $3,000 threshold for services performed in the United States during the tax year.
  • Foreign Employer is not engaged in a USTB: The Canadian company has no U.S. terminal, office, or any other U.S. operations that may qualify as a U.S. trade or business.

Because the above three conditions are met, the personal services exception applies. This means the Canadian driver’s services fall within the personal services exception to USTB. Therefore, the driver is not engaged in a U.S. trade or business.

Overall USTB Analysis

The Canadian trucking company should evaluate its U.S. activities as a whole to determine whether those activities, taken together, constitute a U.S. trade or business.

A Canadian trucking company usually sends its drivers and trucks into the U.S. to carry out pickups, deliveries, and other transport tasks. The fact that this happens could suggest that these activities are substantial, continuous, and aimed at making a profit.

On the other hand, the performance of personal services by the Canadian drivers through transportation services may also result in a USTB, subject to exceptions.

The USTB analysis should be considered at the following two levels:

  • The company’s overall level of U.S. business activity and
  • the specific rules governing performance of personal services by the drivers in the United States.

No single factor automatically determines the result. Instead, examine the company’s complete pattern of U.S. activities.

If the company is determined to be engaged in a USTB, the next question is whether its income from the transportation business is effectively connected with that U.S. trade or business (ECI).

Step 2 — Is the Income Effectively Connected Income?

Once a Canadian trucking company is determined to be engaged in a U.S. trade or business (USTB), the next question is as follows:

Whether the company’s income is effectively connected income (ECI).

Effectively connected income (ECI) refers to the income that is sufficiently connected with the conduct of a U.S. trade or business. If a foreign corporation earns ECI, that income may be subject to U.S. federal income tax under the U.S. domestic rules.

For a trucking company, the key question is therefore:

Which income is connected with the company’s U.S. trucking activities?

Consider a Canadian trucking company that earns revenue from transporting freight between Canada and the United States. Let’s assume that the trucking company is engaged in a U.S. trade or business.

If the company’s drivers regularly enter the United States to pick up or deliver freight, it may earn some transportation revenue associated with those U.S. business activities. In that case, the revenue income associated with U.S. trade or business may be considered when determining the company’s ECI.

For example, assume a Canadian trucking company receives $1 million of transportation revenue during the year. Its drivers regularly enter the United States to perform transportation services. Let’s assume the Canadian trucking company is engaged in a U.S. trade or business.

The company needs to work out the amount of its income that is effectively linked to its trade or business in the United States according to the relevant U.S. tax rules.

It is important since the fact that a company has a USTB does not mean that all of its foreign income is treated as ECI.

The company should generally determine which income items are effectively connected with the U.S. business and which are not.

The company should also determine which expenses and deductions are properly allocable to its ECI. These deductions may include appropriate business expenses connected with generating the income, subject to the applicable U.S. tax rules.

Therefore, assessing whether the Canadian trucking company has federal tax obligations requires answering the following two questions.

  • USTB: Does the company’s activity constitute a trade or business in the United States?
  • ECI: Which income is sufficiently connected with that U.S. trade or business?

A Canadian company may have a USTB and ECI under U.S. domestic law, but the Canada-U.S. Tax Treaty may limit the United States’ right to tax that income. As a result, the treaty may provide relief from U.S. taxation for the Canadian trucking company.

So the next key question that the Canadian company should look into is the following:

 Even if the income is ECI under U.S. domestic law, does the U.S.-Canada treaty allow the United States to tax it?

Thus, let’s take a look at how the U.S. Canada treaty may protect the Canadian trucking company from U.S. federal taxation on its transportation profits.